by Mack Samples
23 Shots is the true story of one of West Virginia’s
most notorious shootouts.
It took place
in the small town of Boggs, in Webster County in 1894.
The face-to-face gunfight inside a post
office involved five men and more than a dozen innocent bystanders.
The story begins several years earlier in Wise County,
Virginia at the infamous Pound Gap Massacre. Five people were ruthlessly gunned
down in cold blood as a result of infighting between different factions in the
raging moonshine wars of the time.
Calvin and Henan Fleming were known far and wide for not only
being experts with their guns, but also willing to frequently use them. When
convincing but circumstantial evidence was brought forth in their involvement in
the Pound Gap Massacre, the brothers hid out but found increasing pressure to
leave the area.
23 Shots chronicles the Fleming brothers journey to
Boggs, their seemingly well-thought out integration back into society, and the
persistent and dogged determination of three men that were determined to capture
the Fleming boys, either dead or alive.
While 23 Shots is a novel, it is based on actual
events. The two main shootouts in the story are based on historical records and
oral history.
The shootout that occurred
at the Boggs post office on that cold winter day back in 1894 was as dramatic as
the gunfight at the OK Corral in Tombstone, Arizona—it just never got the
notoriety.
This is the 9th book by Mack Samples.
Samples
recounts how he became interested in this unique but neglected part of West
Virginia history, “I first learned about the shootout in the classic book,
Tale of the Elk by Bill Byrne.The shootout did not occur on the Elk River
but Byrne was a lawyer in the shootout case and provided a brief summary of the
event.
He mentioned, but did not elaborate
on why it occurred, but it caught my interest.”
Then
Samples read a bit more about the shootout in Skip Johnson’s
River on the
Rocks
, which he says, “…provided a little more background and I started to
dig deeper about how it all started in Wise County, Virginia. I also started
prying around a bit to see if anything had been written about the shootout
other than those two brief descriptions and found that nothing had been
done.
I also learned that most people
who currently live in Webster County or central West Virginia did not know
anything about it.
My wife grew up in
Cowen and her relatives knew nothing of it.”
Mack
believes the shootout in Boggs was the equal of the famous shootout at the O.K.
Corral but, “it never got any mention in the national news media.
Perhaps it was because it occurred in a very
isolated area and happened
before
the big timber and coal boom hit Webster County.”
Samples
went down to Wise County Virginia to research this book, and, “I was surprised
to learn what a violent part of the country that was back during that era.
I was also surprised to learn that Henan and
Calvin Fleming who were the participants on one side of the shootout at Boggs
came from a background of very violent people and were fugitives from
justice.
I also learned that Henan
Fleming had a streak of kindness in him despite his violent nature.
“My research in Virginia sort of led me to
believe that folks in that part of the country often took the law into their
own hands.
Perhaps it was partly
because there just wasn’t enough law to go around in those isolated mountains.
“The shootout in Boggs was the finale of
the infamous Pound Gap Massacre which occurred near the Virginia/Kentucky
border.
A movie made in the 1930s
starring Henry Fonda was based on that massacre.
The movie was entitled Trail
of the Lonesome Pines
but it did not follow the facts very well at all.”
For
anyone interested in the Pound Gap Massacre, or the Boggs shootout, this will
be the definitive account to refer to. Much insight into the culture and way of
life from this era is also shown in rich detail, documenting a way of life and
mentality that few of us could imagine today.
About the author:
Mack Samples was born and raised in Corton, WV.Since his retirement in 1999 Mack has
enjoyed a successful career as a writer.
His band, The Samples Brothers, has been active since 1978 and still
performs on the festival circuit and other venues.
He is a well known as a traditional square dance caller.He and his wife, Thelma, are also ballroom
dancers.
They live on a 55-acre spread
in Duck, WV.
June 8, 2013
Book review: '23 Shots' puts spin on 1894 W.Va. gunfight
"23 Shots." By Mack
Samples. Quarrier Press. 112 pages. $9.95.
CHARLESTON, W.Va.
-- Mack Samples is best known as a talented West Virginia musician (and Vandalia
Award winner). But Samples is also a prolific author who's published a number of
books, both fiction and nonfiction. His latest combines a bit of both. In "23
Shots," Samples takes a real 1894 gunfight in Webster County and puts his own
imaginative spin on it.
The story actually
starts two years earlier, in 1892, at the Pound Gap of Pine Mountain on the
Virginia/Kentucky border. There, Ira Mullins, a local moonshiner, and his family
were ambushed by three men: Doc M.B. Taylor, known as the "Red Fox," and two
brothers, Henan and Calvin Fleming. The ambush killed five of the seven people
in the Mullins party and is remembered in local history as the "Pound Gap
Massacre."
The three killers
escaped. Eventually, Taylor hid out at his son's house in Norton, Va. His son
convinced him he could escape to Florida by train. Taylor boarded an empty
boxcar en route to Bluefield, where he hoped to hop another freight.
Unfortunately for him, the Baldwin Felts Detective Agency somehow learned of his
plans, arrested him and returned him to Virginia for trial. He was convicted and
hanged.
The Fleming
brothers were more successful at eluding capture. But ultimately they decided to
flee to West Virginia, where they had family living in the tiny Webster County
mountain community of Boggs. Samples, exercising a bit of poetic license, offers
an imaginary passage in which Henan Fleming tells his wife what he's decided to
do. He admits he "ain't got the slightest notion where the hell Boggs is" but
figures the law will never find them there.
Samples renders a
richly detailed account of the two brothers' arduous trip to Webster County,
first by train, then by horseback and ultimately by foot. Arriving at Boggs,
they find work at a sawmill and seem to be blending in to the rural
community.
But Henan
underestimates the zeal of Big Ed Hall, who's determined to bring the brothers
in for the Mullins murders. Two years after the killings, Hall gets word that
the two men are living at Boggs and so sets out for West Virginia. Arriving, he
gets word that the Flemings, like the loggers and others living in the area,
generally visit the local post office on Saturday mornings to get their mail and
trade gossip.
And so on Saturday,
Jan. 24, 1894, Hall and two other Virginia lawmen burst through the post office
door, guns already cocked and ready for action. Calvin Fleming fires the first
shot and the two outlaws and three lawmen quickly exchange
fire.
A total of 23 shots
ring out. When the gun smoke clears, Calvin lay dead, with three bullets in him.
One of the Virginia lawmen is fatally wounded; he would die nine days later.
Henan, Hall and the other Virginia lawman are wounded. Amazingly, although a
dozen other people were crowded into the post office when the gunfire erupted,
none of them are hit.
History records
that a Webster County grand jury indicted Henan for murder in the post office
shooting, but he was acquitted. He then was taken back to Virginia and put on
trial for the Mullins murders. Again he was acquitted. Later, he and his wife
would move to West Virginia, where he ultimately became a policeman in Richwood.
Truth, it seems, is indeed stranger than fiction.
Samples believes
the shootout at the Boggs post office was the equal of the famous gunfight at
the O.K. Corral in Tombstone, Ariz., but "it never got any mention in the
national news media. Perhaps it was because it occurred in a very isolated area
and happened before the big timber and coal boom hit Webster
County."
Be that as it may,
Samples' slim paperback novel does an excellent job of bringing to life this all
but forgotten piece of bloody West Virginia history.
"23 Shots" is
available at bookstores throughout West Virginia, or by phone or online from the
West Virginia Book Co. at 304-342-1848 orwww.wvbookco.com.
Retired Huntington
newspaper editor James E. Casto frequently reviews books for the Sunday
Gazette-Mail.